Financial Reporting & Cost Accounting
Display

Theme

Text size

Font

Night is a warm, low-blue theme for reading after dark. Your choices are remembered on this device.

Download PDF(PDF)
Session 3

Understanding and Managing Cost

Session by Prof. Manju Jaiswall · Financial Reporting & Cost Accounting

A different lens: inside the business

Sessions 1 and 2 read a company from the outside, as an investor, banker or regulator would. Session 3 turns the camera round. You are now inside the business, planning budgets, setting prices, deciding whether to launch a product, and deciding whether to close a division.

Financial accounting (Sessions 1–2)Management / cost accounting (Session 3)
AudienceShareholders, banks, regulatorsManagers inside the firm
FormatStandardised by ICAI; no discretionNo fixed format; build what you need
Safety netAuditors catch errorsNone. A wrong analysis costs the business.
Time focusRecords what already happenedHelps you decide before you act
ReportsPublic, formal annual reportPrivate, flexible, purpose-built

“The mother system is the same. But today we are looking at its other arm, and the audience is you: the internal decision-maker.” Prof. Manju Jaiswall

Classifying cost

Start with the cost object

Before you classify a single rupee, decide what you are costing: a product, a batch, a programme, a project, a customer, a department. That is the cost object, and everything else depends on it.

“Cost does not exist in a vacuum. It always exists in a context. Define the cost object first; everything else follows.” Prof. Manju Jaiswall

Direct vs indirect

Direct costIndirect cost (overhead)
DefinitionTraced directly and conveniently to the cost objectCan’t be traced easily; must be allocated
Link to outputClear and highIndirect; needs a proxy
ExamplesPlastic in a computer; study material for EPBM-32Factory rent, supervisor salary, insurance, machine depreciation
How assignedMeasured directlyThrough a cost driver: units, machine hours, participants

Why the driver choice matters more today. Overhead used to be about 20% of total cost, so a poor driver barely mattered. Automation has cut direct labour, and overhead is now 40–50% of cost in many industries. A poor driver on that base produces large costing errors, which flow straight into wrong prices and wrong strategy.

1 Direct material Material that physically becomes the product. Plastic for computers; cloth for shirts. Traced directly.
2 Direct labour + direct expenses Labour and costs tied directly to making it. Assembly workers; machine power. Traced directly.
3 Manufacturing overhead All indirect manufacturing costs, pooled. Factory rent; supervisors; factory lighting. Allocated with a driver.

Box 1 + Box 2 + Box 3 = total manufacturing cost.

Product cost vs period cost

Product costPeriod cost
TimingTravels with the product through inventoryHits the P&L in the period it is incurred
Becomes an expenseOnly when the product is sold (as COGS)Immediately, in full
ExamplesDirect material, direct labour, manufacturing overheadAdvertising, sales commissions, head-office admin
NumbersSpend Rs.5L making 100 computers, sell 80: Rs.4L is COGS, Rs.1L stays as inventoryRs.50,000 of advertising, 80 of 100 sold: the full Rs.50,000 hits the P&L

Product cost ≠ manufacturing cost

Manufacturing cost is what it costs to make the product. It becomes an expense (COGS) only when units are sold; until then it sits on the balance sheet as inventory, an asset. Period costs hit the P&L in full, even if nothing is sold.

How costs behave as volume changes

Fixed and variable cost, total and per unit

Fixed cost: total volume → Stays the same at any volume
Fixed cost: per unit volume → Falls as volume rises
Variable cost: total volume → Rises in step with volume
Variable cost: per unit volume → Stays the same per unit
All four statements are true and all four are tested.
TypeTotal as volume risesPer unit as volume risesExample
FixedConstantFallsFactory rent Rs.50,000/month: Rs.500/unit at 100 units, Rs.250 at 200
VariableRises proportionallyConstantPlastic at Rs.100/computer: Rs.10,000 for 100, Rs.20,000 for 200

Mixed costs: splitting fixed from variable

Many real costs are part fixed, part variable. An electricity bill has a fixed standing charge plus a charge per unit used. For CVP every mixed cost must be split. The high–low (simultaneous equation) method uses two periods of data:

MonthPower costChargeable hoursEquation
January$1,633361 (329 revenue + 32 service)1,633 = X + 361Y
February$1,592348 (316 revenue + 32 service)1,592 = X + 348Y
Subtract$4113 hoursY = 41 ÷ 13 ≈ $3.15 per hour
SubstituteX = 1,633 − 3.15 × 361 ≈ $495 fixed per month

Why the class answer is $4 an hour

The January–February pair alone gives about $3.15 an hour. In class, Prof. Jaiswall averaged three pairs (Jan–Feb, Feb–Mar, Jan–Mar), which comes to about $4 an hour. If a question gives you one pair, calculate from that pair. If it cites the Prestige class figure, use $4.

With power at about $4 and operations salaries at $24, Prestige’s variable cost is about $28 per revenue hour, tiny next to its $800 commercial rate. Each commercial hour contributes $772 towards fixed costs. Prestige’s problem isn’t its cost structure. It isn’t selling enough hours.

The contribution income statement

“I could have just given you the CVP formulas. But once you understand the contribution income statement, the model falls out naturally.” Prof. Manju Jaiswall

Traditional formatContribution format
StartSalesSales
First deductionCOGS (a mix of fixed and variable)All variable costs (variable COGS + variable selling)
SubtotalGross profitContribution margin
Next deductionSelling and admin (a mix)All fixed costs
Bottom lineNet profitNet profit: exactly the same number
Separates costs byFunctionBehaviour
Can it answer “what if we sell 50 more?”NoYes: profit = contribution per unit × units − fixed costs

The contribution format is the prerequisite for CVP: no break-even or target-profit analysis without first splitting fixed from variable. Traditional format is for external reporting; contribution format is for internal decisions.

CVP: building the model from first principles

StartRevenue − Cost = Profit
Expand(P × Q) − (V × Q) − F = Profit. P price, Q units, V variable cost per unit, F fixed costs.
Break-evenSet profit = 0, so Q = F ÷ (P − V).
Target profitQ = (F + Target profit) ÷ (P − V)

Why it works. P − V is the contribution per unit: how fast each unit fills the fixed-cost hole. F is the size of the hole. Hole size ÷ fill rate = units needed. Once you see it that way you never need to memorise the formula.

In sales value: break-even sales = F ÷ CS ratio, where the CS (contribution-to-sales) ratio = contribution per unit ÷ price.

Worked example: Yule Inc. surfboards

ItemValue
Price (P)$500
Variable cost (V)$300
Contribution per board$200
CS ratio200 ÷ 500 = 40%
Fixed costs per month (F)$80,000
Break-even80,000 ÷ 200 = 400 boards, or 80,000 ÷ 40% = $200,000 of sales
Current sales500 boards ($250,000)
Current profit500 × 200 − 80,000 = $20,000
Boards for $100,000 profit(80,000 + 100,000) ÷ 200 = 900 boards
0$100k$200k$300k$400k 0200400600800 Surfboards sold per month Break-even: 400 boards, $200k ↘ Loss Profit
Below 400 boards every sale narrows the loss; above it, each board adds $200 of profit.

Manager takeaway: three numbers before any launch

Break-even is the first question before any investment, launch or expansion. You need three numbers: fixed cost, variable cost and price.

  • Product launch: a health snack with variable cost Rs.1,200, price Rs.2,000. Contribution Rs.800, CS ratio 40%, fixed overhead Rs.4,00,000 a month. Break-even = 500 units or Rs.10,00,000 a month. Ask sales: can we commit to 500 units a month by month four? If not, cut fixed overhead or raise the price before launch.
  • New consulting line: Rs.40,000 variable cost per engagement, Rs.1,00,000 price, Rs.60,000 contribution (CS 60%), Rs.4,80,000 fixed a month. Break-even = 8 engagements a month. If winning 8 by Q2 is uncertain, start with a smaller fixed team.

Never recommend a launch, expansion or new geography without computing break-even and stress-testing the volume assumption.

CVP in action

Margin of safety

Margin of safety (MOS) = actual sales − break-even sales. It is how far sales can fall before you start losing money; a small MOS means you are close to the edge.

Yule: $250,000 − $200,000 = $50,000 (100 boards).

Shortcut: Profit = MOS sales × CS ratio. $50,000 × 40% = $20,000. Past break-even, every dollar of sales adds the CS ratio straight to profit.

What-if questions

QuestionWorkingAnswer
Spend $10,000 more on advertising to lift sales from 500 to 540 boards?Extra contribution 40 × $200 = $8,000 vs cost $10,000Reject (−$2,000). Any spend under $8,000 would add profit.
Variable cost rises from $300 to $310. New break-even?80,000 ÷ 190 = 421.05422 boards (from 400). Cost inflation tightens break-even.
Next year: 525 boards, $190 contribution, $90,000 fixed. Profit?525 × 190 − 90,000$9,750

More than one product

Use a weighted-average contribution based on the sales mix: find total break-even units, then split them by the mix.

ProductPriceVariable costContributionUnitsMixWeighted
Surfboards$500$300$20050062.5%$125.00
Sailboards$1,000$450$55030037.5%$206.25
Combined800100%$331.25

With fixed costs of $170,000: 170,000 ÷ 331.25 = 513.2, so 514 units: 321 surfboards and 193 sailboards.

Always round break-even up

At 513 units contribution is 513 × $331.25 = $169,931, still $69 short. Break-even means fully covered, so round up, never to the nearest whole number.

Prestige Telephone: the shutdown decision

Prestige Telephone is a regulated utility in 1999 whose prices the government controls. President Daniel Rowe noticed that the mainframe running telephone operations sat idle much of the day, so he set up Prestige Data Services to sell those hours: $800/hour to outside businesses, $400/hour to the parent. Three years on, it has never had a profitable month. It is April 2003. Should Rowe shut it down?

HoursJanuaryFebruaryMarchWhat to notice
Intracompany206181223Recovering, strong in March
Commercial123135138Rising slowly
Service / maintenance323240Unavoidable upkeep
Idle223164143Falling fast: the key positive signal

Q1. Close it? Avoidable vs unavoidable costs

The P&L shows a loss and instinct says close. That answers the wrong question. The right one: is Rowe better off with the subsidiary open or closed?

CostMonthlyGoes away if closed?Why
Computer lease$95,000NoNon-cancellable, four years left
Rent + custodial$9,240NoPaid to the parent; the money stays in the group
Depreciation$26,180NoNon-cash; the equipment is already paid for
Corporate services (allocated parent staff)~$15,300Largely noParent staff stay employed anyway
Subsidiary staff salaries~$62,000YesHired for this business; they leave if it closes
Maintenance, power, materials~$17,000YesOnly used when the machine runs
Sales and marketing~$7,700YesDiscretionary; stops on closure

If Prestige Data Services closes (March 2003, $ per month)

March revenue is worked out from the hours: 223 intracompany × $400 + 138 commercial × $800. Avoidable costs are from the course analysis.

Verdict: do not shut down

Closing saves about $87,000 a month but gives up about $200,000 of revenue, while the lease, rent and depreciation (about $130,000) keep running either way. Rowe would be significantly worse off closing.

The P&L loss is the wrong number

March’s accounting loss of $21,438 is real, but it answers “how much did the subsidiary make?” Rowe’s question is “am I better off with it or without it?” Only relevant-cost analysis answers that, and here the two give opposite answers. Never close a unit on a P&L loss alone.

Q2. How many commercial hours to break even?

StepAmount
Total monthly fixed costs (Q1 2003 average)~$213,000
Covered by intracompany hours (205 × $372 contribution)~$76,260
Gap for commercial hours to fill~$136,740
Contribution per commercial hour ($800 − $28)$772
Break-even commercial hours (136,740 ÷ 772)~177 a month
Actual commercial hours (Q1 average)~132 a month
Gap~45 hours a month

This is not a cost problem. It is a sales problem with a specific, achievable target.

Q3. Four options

A Reject Raise price to $1,000/hr Demand falls 30%: hours drop from 132 to 92. Lose 40 × $772 = $30,880; gain $200 × 92 = $18,400. Net: about $12,480 worse a month
B Study further Cut price to $600/hr Demand rises 30% to 172 hours. The volume gain almost offsets the price cut. Marginally worse (about $600 a month)
C Best option Market harder at $800/hr Hours rise to 172 at full price: 40 × $772 = $30,880 more contribution, enough to reach break-even for the first time even after $8,000–9,000 of extra marketing. Any spend below $30,880 beats doing nothing
D Worst option Two-shift operations Commercial hours fall 20% to 106 while the lease stays fixed. Lose 26 × $772 = $20,072 with almost no saving. Loss worsens by about $18,000

Q4. Six fixes to the management report

#ChangeWhy
1Rebuild as a contribution P&LShows strong contribution and that the loss comes from unavoidable fixed costs
2Label costs avoidable vs unavoidableThe $95,000 lease and the $7,700 of marketing look alike on paper; they aren’t
3Split revenue by customer type$800 commercial and $400 intracompany hours are very different contributors
4Put idle hours at the top223 idle hours in January = $178,400 of unsold capacity at the commercial rate
5Flag internal transfersThe $9,240 rent goes to the parent; no cash leaves the group
6Add a break-even tracker“Break-even commercial hours 177, actual 132, gap 45”: a target, not just a loss

Manager takeaway: evaluating a loss-making unit

Close a unit only when the costs you avoid exceed the contribution you lose. Four words: relevant costs only.

  • Specialty chemicals division: revenue Rs.60 lakh a year; avoidable costs Rs.50 lakh (dedicated staff 30, materials 15, marketing 5); unavoidable Rs.55 lakh (allocated lease 40, shared R&D 15). Its P&L shows a Rs.45 lakh loss. Close it and you lose Rs.60 lakh of revenue to save Rs.50 lakh: Rs.10 lakh worse. Keep it open.
  • IT managed-services practice: revenue Rs.45 lakh; avoidable costs Rs.48 lakh (team 40, tools 8); unavoidable Rs.35 lakh. The practice doesn’t even cover its own avoidable costs. Closing saves Rs.48 lakh and gives up Rs.45 lakh: Rs.3 lakh better. Close it. The Rs.35 lakh of shared overhead stays either way and has to be absorbed elsewhere.

The decision is never about the P&L loss; it is about the cash impact of closing.

Manager takeaway: make every report point to an action

  • Plant report: revenue Rs.3.8 crore, cost Rs.4 crore, loss Rs.20 lakh. As a contribution P&L: contribution Rs.1.2 crore, fixed overhead Rs.1.4 crore. Contribution is healthy; the fixed base is the problem. Put machine utilisation at the top (62% vs a 78% target) and the conversation shifts from “we made a loss” to “lift utilisation by 16 points”.
  • SaaS product line: revenue Rs.1 crore a year, variable costs Rs.15 lakh, fixed engineering Rs.1.15 crore, loss Rs.30 lakh. Contribution is Rs.85 lakh, an 85% margin: excellent unit economics. Break-even revenue = 1.15 crore ÷ 85% ≈ Rs.1.35 crore a year, or about Rs.11.3 lakh of monthly recurring revenue against Rs.8.3 lakh today. The team needs about Rs.3 lakh more MRR: an operational target.

Rule: every management report should state the gap to break-even as a specific operational action.