Leadership and People Skills
Display

Theme

Text size

Font

Night is a warm, low-blue theme for reading after dark. Your choices are remembered on this device.

Download PDF(PDF)
Session 1

Theories of Motivation

Session by Prof. Vidyanand Jha · Robbins, Judge & Vohra, Chapters 7 and 8

The question this session answers

A student who can’t read a textbook for twenty minutes will finish a long novel in one sitting. Same brain, same afternoon, very different effort. Motivation is about that gap: not how capable someone is, but what makes them try, in which direction, and for how long.

Prof. Jha opened with two old, opposing answers to why people behave as they do:

  • Nurture. Mowgli, the child raised by wolves, behaves like a wolf. Change the surroundings and you change the behaviour. The same employee behaves differently in six different jobs.
  • Nature. Phrenology, the discredited colonial “science” of reading skull shape to predict criminality, assumed you are born what you are and cannot change.

The truth sits between them, and Organisational Behaviour (OB) studies both.

Micro OB The individual and the group: personality, perception, motivation. Parent disciplines: psychology and social psychology. This session sits here
Macro OB (organisation theory) Structures, systems and processes: the whole organisation in its context. Parent disciplines: sociology, economics, political science. Sessions 3 and 4 lean here

Motivation, defined: three dials

Motivation is the set of processes that account for an individual’s intensity, direction and persistence of effort toward a goal.

1 Intensity How hard someone tries. What most people mean by "motivated", and not enough on its own.
2 Direction Where the effort points. High intensity aimed the wrong way is wasted.
3 Persistence How long the effort lasts. The whole month, not just week one.

A delivery driver who drives hard, on the right route, for the whole month hits the target. Drop any one dial and the target slips.

The early theories: needs

These are the theories everyone has heard of. They are easy to explain and useful for starting a conversation, but the research behind most of them is thin.

Maslow’s hierarchy, and Alderfer’s ERG upgrade

Maslow arranged human needs in five levels. You chase the next level only once the one below is reasonably satisfied. Lower needs are met from outside (pay, security); higher ones from inside (self-respect, growth). The practical instruction: find where a person is on the ladder and motivate at or just above it.

Maslow's five levels, and how ERG regroups them

Self-actualisationBecoming all you can be
EsteemSelf-respect, status, recognition
SocialBelonging, friendship, acceptance
SafetyProtection from harm, security
PhysiologicalFood, water, shelter
Growth
Relatedness
Existence
ERG (right) folds Maslow's five levels into three and drops the strict order: you can pursue all three at once.

Alderfer’s ERG theory collapses the five into Existence, Relatedness and Growth, and makes two changes that matter:

  1. No strict hierarchy. You can care about growth before your existence needs are fully met.
  2. Frustration–regression. When a higher need is blocked, people compensate by demanding more of a lower one.

Frustration–regression explains a pay pattern you see everywhere. A worker on an offshore rig can’t satisfy relatedness for weeks at a time, so the demand regresses to “then pay me more”, and offshore jobs carry a premium. Long-haul truck drivers are cut off from family in the same way but usually get no such premium. Their frustrated need simply goes unanswered.

Maslow’s “fast-forward advantage”

Prof. Jha’s phrase for why managers love Maslow: it is famous and takes thirty seconds to explain. But research barely supports it, because needs don’t queue in a neat order. Use it to open a conversation, not as a literal ladder.

Herzberg’s two-factor theory

Herzberg asked people to describe times they felt exceptionally good or bad about their jobs. The two lists were made of different things. His conclusion: satisfaction and dissatisfaction are not opposite ends of one scale. They are two separate scales.

Two separate scales

MotivatorsAchievement · recognition · responsibility · advancement · growth
No satisfactionSatisfaction

Enrich the work itself to move people right.

Hygiene factorsPay · policy · supervision · working conditions · job security
DissatisfactionNo dissatisfaction

Fixing these only gets you to neutral: no complaints, no extra drive.

A clean canteen and market pay get you to “no complaints”. The chance to own a project end to end is what creates real drive.

Common mix-up

The opposite of satisfaction is no satisfaction. The opposite of dissatisfaction is no dissatisfaction. Removing a hygiene problem never creates satisfaction; it only removes dissatisfaction.

The method draws fair criticism: people credit themselves for the good times and blame their surroundings for the bad. Yet the theory is used widely, including across Asia, and its core recommendation, enrich the work itself, has held up.

McClelland’s theory of needs

Three needs, acquired through life and held in different mixes by different people.

Need for achievement (nAch) The drive to excel against a standard. High achievers prefer roughly 50–50 odds: easy wins give no satisfaction, impossible ones no challenge.
Need for power (nPow) The need to influence and have impact on others.
Need for affiliation (nAff) The desire for friendly, close relationships.

The best managers tend to be high in nPow and lower in nAff. A manager who needs to be liked struggles with hard calls. In the classic beanbag-toss test, a high achiever picks the middle target, challenging but winnable, rather than the near-impossible jackpot. The catch: these needs are hard to measure, so the theory helps you understand people more than it helps you sort them.

The contemporary theories: better evidence

These are the theories to lean on when you actually have to decide something.

Self-determination theory

People want to feel their actions are their own. Three psychological needs drive us: autonomy (control over what we do), competence (being good at it) and relatedness (connection with others).

Its most useful sub-idea is cognitive evaluation theory: adding an external reward to a task someone already enjoys can reduce their interest in it. Once you are paid to do it, it starts to feel like something you have to do. In the textbook example, a woman who happily volunteered fifteen hours a week at an animal shelter found the joy draining away once the shelter hired her to do the same work for pay.

A related idea, self-concordance, is how well your reasons for pursuing a goal fit your own values. People who pursue goals for intrinsic reasons are happier and enjoy the striving whether or not they win.

Beyond the notes: when rewards help and when they hurt

The crowding-out effect is strongest when the reward is expected and tied to simply doing the task, and when it feels controlling. Rewards that are unexpected, or that recognise genuine competence (“this was excellent work”), tend not to damage intrinsic interest. For interesting work: pay people fairly and well, so money is off the table, then let recognition and autonomy do the motivating.

Goal-setting theory and MBO

“Just do your best” is one of the least useful instructions a manager can give. Locke’s goal-setting theory shows that specific, difficult goals, with feedback, produce higher performance than vague or easy ones.

Specific beats vague. "12 round trips a week" beats "do better".
Difficult beats easy, once the goal is accepted.
Feedback beats silence. Self-generated feedback is the most powerful kind.

Three things decide whether goals work: commitment to the goal, the task (simple, independent tasks respond best) and national culture.

Management by Objectives (MBO) puts goal-setting into practice: organisation-wide goals cascade into specific, verifiable, time-bound goals at every level, set together with the people who must deliver them.

Goals have a dark side

Wells Fargo’s aggressive cross-selling targets (eight products per customer) led staff to open around two million accounts customers never asked for. Specific, difficult goals work, but unrealistic goals tied to rewards invite cheating. As one group of researchers (Ordóñez, Schweitzer and colleagues) put it, goals work like a prescription drug: powerful, with side effects, so dose them carefully.

Self-efficacy theory

Self-efficacy is your belief that you can do a specific task. People with high self-efficacy try harder after negative feedback; people with low self-efficacy give up. Bandura identified four ways to build it, in order of strength:

Enactive masteryActually doing the task successfully. The strongest source by far.
Vicarious modellingWatching someone similar to you succeed. A peer, not a champion.
Verbal persuasionA credible person convincing you that you can.
ArousalGetting psyched up. Helps effort tasks; hurts tasks needing calm precision.

Watching a world champion won’t lift your golf confidence. Watching a friend with your handicap sink the putt will.

The Pygmalion effect is the same idea seen from the manager’s side: one person’s expectation makes itself come true. Teachers told that certain (randomly chosen) students were gifted gave them more attention and harder work, and those students really did achieve more. Goal-setting and self-efficacy reinforce each other here: setting someone a difficult goal tells them you believe in them.

Reinforcement and social learning

Where goal-setting is about intentions, reinforcement theory ignores the inner state altogether: behaviour is a function of its consequences. People repeat rewarded behaviour and drop unrewarded behaviour, and rewards work best when they come immediately (Skinner’s operant conditioning). Strictly, it is not a theory of motivation, but it is a powerful way to analyse what controls behaviour.

Social-learning theory extends it: we also learn by watching others. A model’s influence depends on four processes.

AttentionWe notice the model
RetentionWe remember what they did
Motor reproductionWe can actually do it
ReinforcementWe are rewarded for doing it

A new hire copies how a respected senior handles an angry client: noticing, remembering, being able to imitate, and being praised when they do.

Expectancy theory: the spine of the session

Vroom’s expectancy theory says the strength of effort depends on three linked beliefs. If the answer to any one is “no”, motivation collapses.

Expectancy theory

Effort"If I try hard…"
Expectancy
Performance"…will it show up as good performance?"
Instrumentality
Reward"…will I really be rewarded?"
Valence
Personal goal"…and is it a reward I want?"

Motivation = Expectancy × Instrumentality × Valence

Each link is scored from 0 to 1 and the three multiply, so a zero anywhere zeroes the whole thing.

This is why so many capable people do only the minimum: one link has quietly broken for them.

Broken linkWhat the employee is thinkingThe fix
Expectancy“However hard I try, I can’t hit that number” or “the appraisal won’t see it”Training, resources, realistic targets, fair appraisal
Instrumentality“Last year’s top performers got the same increment as everyone else”Visibly tie rewards to performance, and keep promises
Valence“The reward is a photo with the CEO. I’d rather have the money”Let people choose their reward

The valence example is real: a quality programme rewarded the best team with a photo with the CEO, and the workers asked if they could skip the photo and have the money. The standard fix is cafeteria-style rewards: “we’ll spend this amount on you, you choose how”. A young employee takes course fees; an older one takes medical cover.

Equity theory and organisational justice

We don’t judge rewards on their own; we compare. We take the ratio of our outcomes (pay, recognition) to our inputs (effort, experience) and compare it with a referent, usually someone similar.

Fairness is a ratio, not an amount

My outcomes ÷ my inputsWhat I get for what I put in
compared with
Referent’s outcomes ÷ inputsWhat a comparable person gets

Equal ratios feel fair. Unequal ratios create tension that people act to remove.

When the ratios don’t match, people act in one of six ways: change their inputs (work less), change their outcomes (push for more), distort how they see themselves, distort how they see the other person, pick a different referent, or leave.

In the class example, Biprajeet earns ₹40,000 a month and is less satisfied than Aneesha on ₹20,000, because he compares himself with managers at other firms who earn more. Higher pay, lower satisfaction: his referent changed.

Equity broadens into organisational justice, which has four parts:

Distributive Are the outcomes fair?
Procedural Is the process used to decide them fair?
Informational Are we given truthful explanations?
Interpersonal Are we treated with dignity and respect?

Manager takeaway: fair process protects you when the outcome is bad

You can’t always give people the raise or promotion they want. You can always explain the decision honestly, use a process they can see, and treat them with respect. People accept disappointing outcomes far more readily when procedural, informational and interpersonal justice are intact.

Job engagement

Engagement is the investment of a person’s physical, cognitive and emotional energy in their work, deeper than simply liking the job. It rises when the work feels meaningful, when there are enough resources to do it well, and when the person’s values match the organisation’s. Two cautions: it overlaps heavily with job satisfaction, and over-engagement has a dark side. A nurse completely absorbed in patient care is more effective, but the same total involvement, unchecked, becomes burnout.

Putting it together: the integrated model

None of these theories competes with the others. Expectancy theory provides the spine, and every other theory explains one of its links.

LinkWhat it needsTheories that explain it
Effort → PerformanceAbility, opportunity, a fair appraisal, and goals that direct effortGoal-setting, self-efficacy
Performance → RewardRewards genuinely tied to performance, judged fairReinforcement, equity and justice
Reward → Personal goalRewards that match what the person valuesMaslow, ERG, McClelland, self-determination

One exception: a person high in need for achievement jumps straight from effort to personal goals. They are driven by the work itself, not by the organisation’s rewards.

The manager’s diagnostic question is therefore not “which incentive should I use?” but “which of the three links is broken for this person, and is the reward at the end one they actually value?”

From theory to practice: the manager’s toolkit

Designing the job: the Job Characteristics Model

Any job can be described on five core dimensions, which create three psychological states that drive internal motivation.

Core dimensionMeaningLow vs highCreates
Skill varietyHow many different skills the job usesTurning one part all day vs running a small workshopMeaningfulness
Task identityCompleting a whole, identifiable piece of workMaking table legs vs building the whole cabinetMeaningfulness
Task significanceHow much the job affects other people’s livesSweeping a floor vs ICU nursingMeaningfulness
AutonomyFreedom to schedule and decide how to do the workFollowing a script vs planning your own dayResponsibility
FeedbackHow directly the work shows how well you’re doingWaiting for an annual review vs seeing results dailyKnowledge of results

The five combine into a Motivating Potential Score. Try it: move autonomy or feedback to 1 and watch the score collapse.

Motivating Potential Score

MPS = [(SV + TI + TS) ÷ 3] × Autonomy × Feedback 60 out of a possible 343
The first three dimensions are averaged; autonomy and feedback multiply. A job with no autonomy or no feedback has almost no motivating potential, however varied it is. The effect is strongest for people with high growth needs.

Redesigning jobs

ApproachWhat it doesWatch out for
Job rotationMoves people between tasks of similar skill level. Fights boredom and builds a flexible workforce.Training time and lost productivity at each switch
Job enrichmentAdds higher-level responsibility: planning, deciding, checking your own work. Herzberg’s motivators in practice.Only works if people want more responsibility
Relational job designLets employees see the difference they make to others.Needs real contact, not a poster

The textbook’s case for redesign is a worker who quit a well-paid car assembly-line job for a lower-paid one at a print shop, because doing the same panel all day was turning his brain to jelly. The case for relational design: university fundraisers who spent a few minutes with a student who would receive the scholarship persisted 42% longer on calls and raised nearly twice as much money.

Changing when and where work is done

Flextime Fixed weekly hours, flexible timing around a common core. Cuts absenteeism. Doesn’t suit every job; people who ask can be stigmatised
Job sharing Two or more people split one full-time role. Taps skilled people who can’t work full-time. Compatible partners are hard to find
Telecommuting Working remotely at least two days a week. Better satisfaction, no commute. “Out of sight, out of mind” quietly costs raises and promotions

Giving people a voice

Employee involvement and participation (EIP) uses employees’ input to raise their commitment. Participative management means real joint decision-making with the boss. Representative participation works through a small group, such as works councils (consulted on decisions) or employee board members, as at Volkswagen. Its motivational effect is weaker than direct participation. The failure mode is “we talk, but they don’t listen”: asking for input and then ignoring it is worse than not asking.

Pay and rewards

Pay involves two separate decisions.

1. What to pay: the pay structure. Balance internal equity (what the job is worth inside the firm, found through job evaluation) against external equity (what the market pays, found through pay surveys). Firms choose to lead, match or lag the market. Costco pays above its warehouse-club rivals and gets higher productivity and lower turnover in return: leading the market can pay for itself.

2. How to pay individuals: variable pay.

PlanHow it worksStrengthRisk
Piece rateA fixed amount per unit producedHigh productivityQuantity over quality
Merit payTied to appraisal ratingsRewards individual performanceOnly as fair as the appraisal
BonusOne-off reward for recent performanceDoesn’t inflate base payFeels like an entitlement if routine
Profit sharingPaid from a profitability formulaBuilds commitment, especially in small firmsWeak link to individual effort
GainsharingTeam shares the gains from improved performanceOwnership and cooperationThe formula must be seen as fair
ESOPEmployees own company sharesLong-term ownershipWorks only if people feel like owners and have a say

Flexible benefits let each employee build their own benefits package: expectancy theory’s valence point made concrete. Recognition programmes are the cheapest tool of all, because praise is free yet powerful. The risk is favouritism, so the criteria must be visibly fair.

Manager takeaway: recognition does what money can’t

The textbook tells of an employee on $8.50 an hour, in a job that isn’t challenging, who speaks about it with real enthusiasm. Her supervisor praises her in front of others and named her Employee of the Month. If your budget is tight, recognition is the lever you always have: specific, prompt, public where appropriate, and fair.

The case, briefly: Shivani Carriers

The class case was a family-run Indian trucking firm with a fleet of about ninety trucks and drivers drawn mostly from low-income, rural backgrounds. The drivers’ working life is punishing: very long days, weeks away from family, little respect. Fuel is the biggest cost, and a truck’s fixed costs are the same whether it runs 5,500 or 8,000 km a month, so the driver is the biggest lever on profit.

The owner’s intervention reads like a checklist of this session: a clear monthly kilometre target with per-km incentives above it, results displayed weekly, a “stars of the month” board, a deliberate shift to treating drivers with dignity, and supporting systems so they could rest safely and see their families. It worked, until the scheme was changed after the fact with a new baseline and a cap, and drivers felt the reward had been clawed back.

ConceptWhere it shows up
Maslow / ERG: existenceCash to support the family is the dominant motive
ERG: frustration–regressionRelatedness is blocked by weeks away, so the demand becomes “just pay me more”
HerzbergPay and conditions are hygiene; respect is the real motivator
Goal-settingA specific, accepted monthly target with visible feedback
ExpectancyChanging the scheme after drivers delivered broke the performance → reward link
Equity and justiceDrivers compare themselves with managers; cuts based on suspicion violate interpersonal justice
Self-efficacy / PygmalionTelling drivers they carry responsibility for valuable cargo raises their belief in themselves

The lesson travels well beyond trucking: wherever a job is easily substituted and a higher need is frustrated, the same mechanics apply, and a reward changed after people have earned it does more damage than no reward at all.

Where this leads

Everything so far has been about one person at a time. But almost no real work happens alone. Put motivated people side by side and something new appears that none of them brought: a group, with its own roles, norms and pecking order. That is Session 2.