Global Political Economy
Download PDF
Session 2

Regulatory Risk and Cross-Border Investments

Based on the session by Prof. Biju Paul Abraham and Sammut-Bonnici & Galea (2014), PEST Analysis

Why do firms invest abroad? Four motivations

Every cross-border investment maps onto one or more of these four categories. MCQs often present a fifth fake option like “tax avoidance” or “competitive retaliation”. Neither is on Prof. Abraham’s list.

Motivation What the firm seeks Indian example
① Resources Energy, commodities, human resources not available or cheaper domestically ONGC Videsh investing in Russian and Sudanese oil fields
② Markets New markets to sell into; diversification across existing markets Tata Motors buying JLR to access premium European and US car markets
③ Efficiency Lower costs, better quality, closeness to the market being served Apple manufacturing in India: cost + market proximity + government incentives
④ Strategic assets Acquire R&D, capabilities, brands; bypass institutional constraints; gain a trading-bloc foothold Wipro, HCL buying European IT firms to acquire talent and client relationships

Horizontal vs. vertical FDI

Horizontal FDI: a firm replicates its entire value chain in a host country. It operates in one product category but does so in multiple countries. Think McDonald’s opening restaurants in India: same product, different country.

Vertical FDI: different stages of production are placed in different countries to exploit each country’s specific advantages. Think Boeing 787: wings from Japan, fuselage from Italy, tail from South Korea, trailing edges from Australia, final assembly in Everett, Washington.

Type Scope of risk when disrupted Why?
Horizontal FDI Affects that host-country market only Each country’s operation is self-contained. A problem in India does not stop Germany.
Vertical FDI Can affect third-country and sometimes global markets Each stage feeds the next. Disrupt one node and you break the entire global chain.

Three reasons vertical FDI grew substantially:

  1. Dramatic decline in transport and communication costs (sea freight fell to ~20% of its 1930 cost by 2005).
  2. Substantial reduction in trade barriers through GATT/WTO rounds and regional blocs.
  3. Competitive pressure: once one rival cut costs by going abroad, others had to follow.

Six country risk categories

Before any cross-border investment, firms must assess country-level risk systematically. Know all six. MCQs often give five correct ones and one impostor.

Risk type What it covers Real-world example
① Political Government instability, expropriation, policy reversals, sanctions Venezuela nationalising oil; Russia sanctions post-2022
② Economic GDP contraction, high inflation, recession; market attractiveness declining Eurozone sovereign debt crisis spreading from Greece to Spain, Portugal, Cyprus
③ Transfer Restrictions on repatriating profits, dividends, royalties, or capital China capital controls limiting profit repatriation by foreign multinationals
④ Exchange rate Currency fluctuation making revenues worth less in home-country terms Tata subsidiary earning GBP: INR value swings with the GBP/INR rate
⑤ Location / Neighbourhood Risk from geographic proximity to unstable neighbours, even if the host country is stable Investing in Jordan: affected by instability in Syria and Iraq next door
⑥ Sovereign Risk that government defaults on debt or repudiates its obligations Argentina’s repeated sovereign defaults: every business in-country affected

Exam trap

Cultural Risk or Regulatory Risk offered as a seventh standalone category: neither is on Prof. Abraham’s list. The six above are the complete set.

PEST analysis: the core framework

PEST is a framework for identifying four categories of external macro-environmental factors that affect a firm’s competitive position. It feeds directly into the Opportunities and Threats part of a SWOT analysis.

Golden rule of PEST

Only include factors that (a) have a direct bearing on industry attractiveness and (b) are likely to change in the foreseeable future. Everything else is noise. Without this discipline, PEST becomes an “endless evaluation” with inconclusive results.

① Political factors

They operate at three levels: supranational (WTO, EU), national (government policy), subnational (state/municipal).

  • Trade policies, tariffs, taxation, fiscal policy
  • Labour and environmental legislation
  • Licensing, approval procedures, lobbying
  • Corruption levels, national incentives for enterprise
  • Examples: EU tobacco ad ban led Formula One to move to Dubai. Google left China due to censorship. The Arab Spring made firms rethink MENA strategy.

② Economic factors

These have the most obvious impact on profitability.

  • GDP per capita (at PPP): primary demand indicator for income-elastic industries
  • Inflation erodes purchasing power and raises input costs
  • Exchange rates directly hit margins for international firms
  • Unemployment erodes disposable income but provides cheaper labour
  • Income-elastic industries: jewellery, construction, entertainment, tourism, luxury. Demand swings with GDP.
  • Income-inelastic industries: staple foods, healthcare, basic commodities. Demand stays stable in recession.

③ Social factors

  • Demographics (age, population growth, ageing populations)
  • Psychographics, lifestyle, consumer perception
  • Effect of advertising, influencers, racial/ethnic/religious influences
  • Examples: Ryanair repositioned air travel as a no-frills commodity. Ageing populations mean rising demand for medicines.

④ Technological factors

  • New materials, machinery, software; innovations in processes and product design
  • New distribution channels (e-commerce) and pricing innovations (dynamic pricing, auctions)
  • Disintermediation: technology removes old middlemen (travel agents replaced by online booking)
  • Re-intermediation: technology creates new middlemen. Amazon, eBay, Expedia are not disintermediation; they are re-intermediation.
  • Standard wars: two formats fighting to become the industry standard (e.g. VHS vs Betamax)

PEST variations and the 5-step process

Know all five variations and their distinguishing features. MCQs test the differences precisely.

Framework Adds to PEST Key distinguisher
PEST — Baseline. Political, Economic, Social, Technological.
PESTEL / PESTLE + Environmental + Legal Adds ecology and legal compliance. Same framework, different letter order.
STEEPLE + Environmental + Legal + Ethics Takes a CSR perspective. The ethics addition is deliberate.
STEEPLED + Environmental + Legal + Ethics + Demographics Most comprehensive version. Adds demographic analysis.
STEER + Regulatory factors Created because of increased environmental awareness.

The 5-step PEST process:

  1. Identify: current and future factors in all four environments.
  2. Analyse: the possible effect of each factor on competitive position.
  3. Categorise: each factor as an opportunity or threat (feeds the OT of SWOT).
  4. Prioritise: by extent of impact and how long it will last.
  5. Act: develop strategy. Correct threats, build on opportunities.

Quick exam checks

  • Which takes a CSR perspective? STEEPLE.
  • Which adds Demographics? STEEPLED.
  • Which adds Regulatory? STEER.
  • PEST E = Economic, not Environmental. Environmental appears only in PESTEL/PESTLE.
  • In SWOT, PEST gives O and T. Strengths and Weaknesses are internal.