Global Political Economy
Download PDF
Session 1

Stakeholders and Trust

Based on the session by Prof. Biju Paul Abraham and Crane (2020), Revisiting Who, When, and Why Stakeholders Matter

Why stakeholder identification matters

Every business has an obvious first job: deliver returns to shareholders. But a firm does not operate in a bubble. It sits inside a web of relationships, and each person or organisation in that web can either help the firm succeed or quietly undermine it. The real question is not whether to engage stakeholders, but whether you do it on purpose or get blindsided when you don’t.

Definition of a stakeholder

Any person or institution who is (a) affected by what a firm does, or (b) whose approval the firm may need to act. There is often no legal requirement to engage them, but ignoring them can prove very costly.

Why it matters more than ever: the ESG era. ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) has moved stakeholder management from a box-ticking exercise to a boardroom priority. Investors now screen firms on how they treat employees, communities, and the environment. Getting stakeholders right means long-term success.

The eight stakeholder groups

Prof. Abraham’s PPT identifies exactly eight categories. The two that students miss most are Regulatory Agencies (separate from Government) and the “Others” bucket, which includes Competitors.

Stakeholder What they care about
① Customers Revenue, loyalty, product quality, brand trust
② Investors / Partners Returns, risk, governance quality
③ Employees & Families Jobs, pay, culture, safety, career growth
④ Suppliers & Distributors Contracts, payment terms, supply chain stability
⑤ Government Tax revenue, policy compliance, national interest
⑥ Regulatory Agencies Compliance, licences, safety standards, permits
⑦ Community Social licence, environmental impact, local employment
⑧ Others (NGOs, Media, Environmental Groups, Competitors) Advocacy, public opinion, watchdog, competitive pressure

Exam trap

Regulatory Agencies is a separate group from Government. And “Others” includes Competitors. Both are frequent MCQ surprises.

What do you want from stakeholders?

Identifying stakeholders is only step one. The harder question is what the relationship is actually for. Four questions every manager must answer:

  • Why is this stakeholder important? Force yourself to name the specific value they enable.
  • What role do they play in the firm’s success? Customers = revenue. Employees = execution. Government = licence to operate.
  • How does our relationship with one affect others? The interdependency insight. Connects directly to Crane’s connectedness theory.
  • Can we address all stakeholder needs at once? Often no. But knowing the trade-offs is different from ignoring them.

Watch out

Addressing one stakeholder’s needs can influence how all other stakeholders view you, positively or negatively. You are always sending signals, whether you intend to or not.

Stakeholder relationships are dynamic

Stakeholder management is not a one-time document. It is a living discipline. Four reasons the map constantly shifts:

  • Needs change over time. A regulator’s priorities in 2019 are not those of 2025.
  • Some become irrelevant; new ones emerge. Covid-19 example: vacuum cleaner firms made ventilators; alcohol distilleries made hand-sanitisers. The entire stakeholder universe transformed in weeks.
  • Stakeholders can be replaced or substituted. An NGO partnership can be swapped for a government one.
  • Mapping must be continuous. The PPT is explicit that stakeholder identification and mapping needs to be a continuous process for the firm.

Five pillars of good stakeholder relationships

MCQs often present a list and ask which one is not on the list. Know all five:

Pillar What it means What it is not
① Act in their best interests Genuine good intent, not just performative Acting only when legally required
② Visibility of action Stakeholders must see what you are doing Doing good things in private
③ Explain your motives Communicate why you are acting Silent action with no explanation
④ Respond proactively Act before regulators or courts force you to Reactive compliance = managerial failure (Freeman)
⑤ Transparency & integrity Consistent, honest, and open in all dealings Selective transparency; hiding problems

Most tested pillar

Pillar ④, proactive response. If a question mentions “waiting for regulatory or judicial intervention”, that is the wrong approach per the PPT.

Crane (2020): core argument and trust framework

Crane’s central argument: managers have long tried to prioritise stakeholders because resources are limited. But in the information age this is increasingly dangerous, because stakeholders are interconnected. What you do to one group is now visible to all the others, and sends signals about your trustworthiness across the whole ecosystem.

Trust defined

From Pirson & Malhotra (2011): trust is a stakeholder’s willingness to be vulnerable to a business. When you buy from a firm, work for it, or invest in it, you are taking a risk. Trust is what makes that risk feel acceptable.

The three core trust dimensions (Mayer et al., 1995):

Dimension Meaning Good example Bad example
Ability Operational competence to deliver on promises Mattel: swift global recall of faulty toys Toyota: slow corrective action despite quick statement
Benevolence Genuine care and good intent toward stakeholders Siemens: voluntary USD 100M anti-corruption programme Kia/Hyundai: refused voluntary recall despite faulty parts
Integrity Fairness, consistency; keeping promises; acting on stated values McDonald’s: transparency videos on food appearance Toyota: NHTSA called their statement “inaccurate and misleading”

Three supplementary trust signals

These three signals are how firms demonstrate the three core trust dimensions in practice.

① Voluntary action signals benevolence

Acting without being forced by courts, regulation, or public pressure. Freeman (1984): “A solution imposed by a government agency or courts must be seen as a managerial failure.”

Good: Siemens voluntarily set up a 15-year USD 100M anti-corruption programme. Bad: Kia/Hyundai waited for a forced recall, and trust was destroyed.

② Transparency signals integrity

Sharing clear, accurate information proactively. If you have nothing to hide, you share openly, and stakeholders notice.

Good: McDonald’s Canada ran videos showing why ads look different from real food. Bad: Toyota told dealers to inspect floor mats instead of warning customers directly.

③ Responsiveness signals ability and benevolence

Quickly detecting and acting on stakeholder needs. Two components: timing (act fast, because in the absence of information stakeholders assume the worst) and ability (you can actually fix the problem).

Good: Mattel recalled 2/3 of affected toys globally and ran a full marketing campaign. Bad: Toyota made a fast statement but was slow to act, blamed on its hierarchical structure.

The six propositions (Crane 2020)

These six propositions are high-value for MCQs. The most counter-intuitive is P6.

Prop. What it says Why it matters
P1 Actions toward one stakeholder provide trust cues to all others. Foundation of the whole argument. Nothing happens in isolation.
P2 Voluntary actions increase trust of observing stakeholders. Benevolence inferred from voluntary action transfers to the whole audience.
P3 Transparent actions increase trust of observing stakeholders. Integrity signals generalise: open with one = seen as open with all.
P4 Responsive actions increase trust of observing stakeholders. Ability and benevolence demonstrated in one relationship reassures all others.
P5 Proximity amplifies trust effects. Closer stakeholders feel it most. Flint water crisis: all Americans who drink tap water felt the distrust.
P6 ★ Prioritisation of stakeholders decreases trust in the firm. Counter-intuitive. Undermines ability, benevolence, and integrity simultaneously.

Why prioritisation destroys trust (P6 deep dive)

  • Ability: secondary stakeholders wonder “will the firm’s resources ever reach me?”, which reduces their willingness to be vulnerable.
  • Benevolence: it creates a zero-sum mentality, helping some at the expense of others (e.g. Boeing’s USD 9B tax break demand destroyed perceived benevolence).
  • Integrity: any unprioritised stakeholder can call it favouritism (e.g. Wells Fargo’s shareholder-first culture led to 1.5M fake accounts and a trust collapse).

Case study reference map

All company examples from the Crane reading. Know the lesson for each:

Company Situation Key lesson
Mattel ✔ Lead-based paint in toys All 3 dimensions at once: Ability (global recall) + Benevolence (CEO on child safety) + Integrity (consistent campaign). 75% American approval.
Toyota ✘ Acceleration / floor mat crisis Failed Transparency (misleading statement) and Responsiveness (slow action despite fast words).
Volkswagen ✘ Emissions scandal Textbook connectedness: one failure cascaded to customers, employees, suppliers, investors, and government simultaneously.
Nike ✘ Asian factory conditions Workers were suppliers’ employees, yet customers, activists and regulators held Nike responsible. Supply chain is not a shield.
Siemens ✔ Bribery scandal Voluntary action restored partial trust: chairman resigned, voluntary 15-year USD 100M programme.
Wells Fargo ✘ 1.5M fake accounts Shareholder-first targets led employees to create fake accounts. Integrity destroyed; 5,300 fired.
Boeing ✘ Leaving Washington threat USD 9B tax break + pension concessions = zero-sum hardball. Benevolence destroyed across all groups.
McDonald’s ✔ Food appearance campaign Voluntary transparency (videos on why ad food ≠ real food) improved reputation and trust.
Flint, Michigan EPA ✘ Lead in water supply Proximity (P5) example: local EPA failure led to national distrust. Only 47% of Americans believed tap water was safe.